Forum

Forum Navigation
Forum content is readable by default! Create an account and log in to add posts or topics.

Estes D12 CATO

My Estes SASHA 2 stage rocket left the launch pad as planned and then a pop and the second stage lit at about 100’.  The booster fell to the ground in flames.   I flew a D12-0 in the booster and C11-7 in the sustainer.  Based on the rocket weight, the D12 is the smallest motor usable for the booster.

Once the fire was out, I found the spent booster motor casing nearby and began my inspection.  Based on the burn damage, I assume the casing was ejected from the booster leaving the propellant in the airframe.  The fire damage to the booster was severe and the motor casing is unscorched.

Compared to a booster from a successful flight the interior of the casing is very clean, no BP residue, just clean tube wall down to the nozzle.  It appears that the entire plug of BP left the tube and continued burning in the baffle at the top of the booster.  This uncontrolled fireball was enough to ignite the sustainer motor (a few hundred feet early) before destroying the booster.  The rocket was still traveling in a nominal trajectory at the time and resulted in the sustainer having a successful flight under power.  We will skip over the recovery problem with this flight.

Now looking at the aft end of the two motors, you can see where the casing is damaged by both the engine hook at the 2 o’clock position and a larger dent which was not present when this motor was installed.  Looking at the nozzle, only a little burning occurred inside this casing.

I believe this damage occurred it either transport or when setting up on ¼” launch rod.  I had a wrap of blue tape around the engine hook to lock the motor in place.  Only after I removed the tape was the extent of the damage revealed.   I believe this may have a lot to do with the propellant exiting the casing.  No chance of warranty for this one.

One troubling fact.  The forward end of the failed motor casing wall measured 0.1mm thinner than the successful motor.  Yes, they are from the same lot.  Would this matter? Possibly, but the dent shows a significant shock was delivered to this unit and is the most likely cause of the failure. I still wonder if a thin inside layer of cardboard tube delaminated and stayed with the propellant when the casing was kicked out.  We may never know.

While I wouldn’t call these BP motors fragile, rough handling is never recommended.  Use this information as you wish.  Now I need to build another rocket.

Chris Oliver

Uploaded files:
  • PXL_20261102_191806571.jpg
  • PXL_20261102_191840338.jpg
  • PXL_20261102_000538572.MACRO_FOCUS.jpg
  • PXL_20261102_000359649.MACRO_FOCUS.jpg
  • PXL_20261102_171006867.jpg
  • PXL_20261102_170952010.jpg

First, I'm a little confused - you show 2 D12-0 motors. Were both in this rocket, or just one? (I'll assume just the one on the right, and the other was only for comparison.)

Yes, it does look like the motor core was never attached to the casing and left the motor shortly after ignition. Estes might be interested in this picture, however be aware that rumor has it that they are more picky about their warranty process these days. Some folks have been told that they need store receipts for the motor in question. And the latest is that they told someone they would only honor their warranty if the motor was bought from Estes directly, and less then a year or two old. My assumption is that IF true, they have been loosing too much money due to their CATO problems lately and are trying to stem the tide. But I would send it to them anyway (maybe not mention the dents and whatever unless they ask). Maybe they will honor it, and the info I got was wrong. Maybe they will learn something from the clean casing (which to me shows a clear manufacturing defect, regardless of any other marks or dents).

Finally, regardless of what Estes does or does not do, I encourage you to file a MESS report. This builds a record of failure that is of interest to manufacturers and us fliers. (lot numbers with lots of MESS reports fly in my spinny thingy where they can't hurt anything.)

https://www.motorcato.org/

PS: a shame - I liked that rocket. You did a good job building it.

Several CENJARS Forums are only available or visible to CENJARS members.